TAMPA, Fla. — Maybe the Eastern Conference finals were destined to go seven games, what with the Tampa Bay Lightning[1] and the Pittsburgh Penguins[2] battling with equ al parts grit and guile. But the Penguins had raw desperation on their side Tuesday, as well as the return of the rookie goaltender Matt Murray, and they skated to a 5-2 victory.

Pittsburgh evened the series at three games each, turning back a third-period rally by the Lightning, who are looking to become the first team to reach back-to-back Stanley Cup finals since the Penguins in 2008 and 2009.

"We knew the circumstances," Pittsburgh's Sidney Crosby said. "You go out there with the mind-set of playing desperate. It's pretty natural when you're in this situation. Everyone played great tonight. Everyone contributed in their own way, and in a big game like this, you don't have to do anything special; you just have to do your job."

Bryan Rust sealed the victory with a breakaway goal, and Nick Bonino added an empty-netter as Pittsburgh staved off elimination and softened criticism of Coach Mike Sullivan's flip-flopping of goaltenders.

Murray made 28 saves, including several spectacular stops in the final minutes as Tampa Bay rallied from a 3-0 third-period deficit.

"My job isn't to worry about his decision," Murray said of Sullivan. "My job is to be ready if my name is called and to go out and play my heart out."

Pittsburgh built a 2-0 lead on goals by Phil Kessel and Kris Letang, who scored at 7 minutes 40 seconds of the second period when he and Conor Sheary broke into the Lightning zone after a turnover. Sheary made a smooth drop pass to Letang, who ripped a wrist shot high into the left corner.

Two-goal leads have evaporated like swamp water under the Florida sun in this series, but Crosby eased some pressure when he caught Anton Stralman and Nikita Kucherov on their heels with 26 seconds remaining in the period. Crosby skated around both defenders for a clean breakaway and beat goaltender Andrei Vasilevskiy for a 3-0 lead.

Still, the Lightning rallied, cutting their deficit to 3-2 with seven minutes to play. Brian Boyle scored both goals, throwing the puck in front of the net and having it hit Kessel's stick and skate for one score and then firing a wrist shot high over Murray's right shoulder.

Interactive Feature | Sports Newsletter Get the big sports news, highlights and analysis from Times journalists, with distinctive takes on games and some behind-the-scenes surprises, delivered to your inbox every week.

Pittsburgh held the edge in shots after two periods, 26 to 11, but Tampa Bay slowly recovered after being deflated by the disallowal of a goal about five minutes into the game.

The Penguins did not need extra motivation or help in trying to extend the series to a seventh game Thursday night in Pittsburgh. But the Lightning provided both with back-to-back head-scratching penalties late in the first period that led to a 1-0 lead for the Penguins.

First, Stralman was called for interference after decking Tom Kuhnhackl near center ice as the puck passed them both. Then, 41 seconds later, Victor Hedman cleared the zone by firing the puck almost the length of the rink, over the head of Murray and into the netting that protects fans, resulting in a delay-of-game call.

That gave the Penguins a two-man advantage, and they quickly converted. Crosby faked a slap shot from the right face-off circle and directed the puck near the left goal post to Kessel, who chipped in a shot with 74 seconds left.

Pittsburgh's momentum had surged since midway through the first period, when the Lightning briefly celebrated a goal by Jonathan Drouin, only to have it disallowed. The Penguins quickly challenged that Drouin, who was trailing the play, was offside on the scoring rush. Replays clearly showed that Drouin's left skate was slightly in the air as his right skate crossed the blue line.

From there, energy shifted to the Penguins, who outshot the Lightning by 14-4 in the first period and helped justify Sullivan's decision to start Murray after benching him for the veteran Marc-Andre Fleury in Game 5.

"It's just the cards that were dealt," Murray said. "I thought I handled it pretty well. I can't really worry about that stuff. I just have to focus on staying in the moment."

Sullivan had pushed mostly the right buttons in his five months as Penguins coach, but many found the move puzzling. Fleury had played the third period of Game 4 and started Game 5 despite not having played since March 31 after sustaining a concussion.

Murray had fashioned a 9-4 record in the playoffs, but Sullivan was convinced Fleury was ready. After the switch backfired somewhat, Sullivan reversed course and was not afraid to second-guess himself.

"He's won a lot of big games for us," Sullivan said of Murray before Tuesday's game. "He's made timely saves for us. He has a demeanor back there, a calming effect on the group in front of him. I think his performance speaks for itself.

"At this particular point in the season, we don't have the luxury of allowing players to play through things. We have to win a hockey game. That's how we looked at it."